Musical Instruments

Bill Graham Archives v. Dorling Kindersley, Ltd.

Bill Graham Archives v. Dorling Kindersley, Ltd., 448 F.3d 605, is a 2006 case of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit regarding fair use of images in a pictorial history text. It affirmed the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, which held at trial that the publisher's use of several images of past Grateful Dead concert posters and tickets, reduced considerably, in a timeline of the band's history was a sufficiently transformative use. The case began during the pre-production of Grateful Dead: The Illustrated Trip, a coffee table book published by Dorling Kindersley (DK) that included a wide variety of information and imagery, presented in a timeline format beginning with the band's 1965 founding. DK had been negotiating licensing terms with the Bill Graham Archives (BGA), whose holdings include many works created to promote Grateful Dead concerts staged by Bill Graham. After the parties could not reach an agreement on terms for seven images to which BGA held the rights, DK nevertheless decided to use them in the book, which was published in October 2003. BGA sued for copyright infringement in the Southern District. Both parties sought summary judgement. Judge George B. Daniels granted DK's motion for summary judgement in 2005, holding that the use of reduced images to illustrate historic moments in the band's past was sufficiently transformative from their original promotional purpose to make them fair use. On appeal, the Second Circuit's affirmation elaborated on Daniels's reasoning, narrowing his finding that the second factor in the fair use analysis, the nature of the original work, favored BGA, since the transformative use of the works as history limited the relevance of their artistic value. It also distinguished the case from an earlier Second Circuit precedent, limiting the analysis of the fourth factor, the market impact of the allegedly infringing work, to only traditional markets for derivative works.

Also on this shelf

See also

• ▸Disability in the arts
• ▸Helvoetsluys (painting)
• ▸Ancient music

Uncatalogued shelf

Text from Wikipedia; plate via Wikimedia Commons. Text CC BY-SA 4.0; plate freely licensed (see Commons). Source record. Images and catalogue data are reproduced from open-access collections.